Definition:Market study
📋 Market study is a preliminary examination conducted by a competition authority or insurance regulator to assess whether a particular insurance market is functioning effectively for consumers and participants. Unlike a full market investigation, a market study typically lacks compulsory powers and relies on voluntary cooperation, published data, and stakeholder submissions. In the insurance context, market studies have scrutinized areas such as the competitiveness of home insurance markets, the transparency of add-on products sold alongside primary policies, and the effectiveness of price comparison websites in driving genuine consumer choice.
🔎 Conducting a market study generally involves collecting quantitative data on premium levels, market shares, switching rates, and loss ratios, alongside qualitative evidence from insurers, brokers, consumer groups, and insurtech firms. In the UK, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has been particularly active, publishing market studies on general insurance pricing practices that revealed how policyholders who renewed without shopping around were systematically overcharged — findings that directly led to pricing remedies. The European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority ( EIOPA) has conducted similar cross-border studies examining travel insurance and product governance, while regulators in Hong Kong and Australia have undertaken their own insurance market assessments. The conclusions of a market study may recommend voluntary industry reforms, propose new regulatory rules, or — where concerns are serious enough — trigger a formal market investigation with binding enforcement powers.
💡 Although a market study carries no automatic enforcement mechanism, its practical impact on the insurance sector should not be underestimated. Published findings shape public discourse, influence legislative agendas, and often prompt carriers to modify practices preemptively rather than wait for mandated change. The FCA's general insurance pricing study, for instance, fundamentally altered how UK insurers approach renewal pricing, effectively ending the practice of offering deep discounts to new customers while penalizing loyal policyholders. For new market entrants and insurtech challengers, market studies can be strategically valuable — they publicly document incumbents' weaknesses and highlight areas where innovation could address identified consumer harms, providing both a roadmap and a regulatory tailwind.
Related concepts: